A massive planet of radius R has a diametrical hole as shown in figure, such that hole does not effect the spherecityof the planet. The planet has uniform density. Two equal mass and are simultaneously released,from positions shown. If the collisions are elastic then the total distance traveled by mass after being released atthe time of collision is : [ mass of planet, mass of and neglect the gravitational interaction
Detailed Explanation
1. Gravitational field inside a uniform sphere
For any point at a distance from the centre of a uniform sphere (radius , mass ), only the mass inside that radius contributes to the gravitational pull. The effective mass inside radius is
Hence the gravitational acceleration is
which is directly proportional to .
2. Link with Simple Harmonic Motion
Because , the force on a small mass is
This is the same form as the spring force , so the motion is SHM with angular frequency
The time-dependent position for a mass released from the surface () with zero initial speed is
3. When do the two masses collide?
One marble starts at and the other at . Their positions are
They meet when . The first time this happens is at
4. Distance travelled up to the collision
Path length for one marble: it starts at , ends at , so distance Collision is elastic and the masses are equal, so after the impact they merely exchange velocities and carry on; the distance up to the first contact is still .
Simple Explanation (ELI5)
What is happening?
Imagine a huge solid ball (the planet) with a straight, smooth tunnel dug right through the centre from one side to the other.
Now place two identical marbles at the two openings of this tunnel and let them go at the same time.
Because the planet pulls everything towards its centre, each marble begins to slide inward.
Inside a uniform sphere, that pull (gravity) gets weaker the closer you get to the centre, in just the right way to make the motion a perfect back-and-forth swing, just like a spring.
So each marble acts like it is on a giant, invisible spring: it starts at the edge (maximum stretch), heads to the centre (where the spring is relaxed), then would go out the other side.
Where do they bump into each other?
Both marbles start at opposite edges, so they meet exactly in the middle at the very same time.
How far has each marble actually slid when they meet?
They started at the edge (distance from centre) and travelled straight to the centre (distance ).
That means each marble covered a path‐length of exactly metres before bumping.
So, when the problem asks "total distance travelled by a marble until the collision", the answer for one marble is simply . (If it had asked for both marbles together, it would be .)
Step-by-Step Solution
Step-by-step calculation
-
Gravitational field inside planet
-
Equation of motion (restoring force )
where -
SHM solution for an object released from with zero initial speed
-
Collision time: first time when
-
Distance travelled by one mass up to collision
Straight-line motion from to
[ \boxed{\text{Distance} = R} ] (If the question had asked for the combined distance of both masses, it would be .)
Examples
Example 1
Weightlessness felt inside a lift in free fall is similar to the zero effective gravity at the planet's centre in this problem.
Example 2
Seismic waves passing through Earth’s interior experience varying acceleration fields somewhat like the varying gravity considered here.
Example 3
Magnetic traps for charged particles use forces proportional to displacement, creating SHM just like the gravity field inside a uniform sphere.
Visual Representation
References
- [1]H. C. Verma – Concepts of Physics, Part-1 (Gravitation chapter)
- [2]I. E. Irodov – Problems in General Physics, Problem 1.14 (tunnel through Earth)
- [3]Resnick & Halliday – Fundamentals of Physics, ‘Gravitation inside Earth’ section
- [4]MIT OCW – Classical Mechanics, Lecture on Gravitational SHM (searchable online video)